It must be the season of giving, though I thought that was around the holidays. It was a bit odd, but both my wife and I received mailings from our alma maters at the same time this year. I was a bit surprised because you would think the end of January would be the worst time to ask for donations. People are still hung over from the holidays and the credit card bills for the excesses of December have started to arrive.
The two mailings arrived, but they were two very different packages with two different approaches. My wife opened the letter with the usual mild anticipation of the school’s quarterly newsletter. Instead she received a form letter by the president of the college, seeking donations. What I received surprised me a bit. I opened my envelope, slightly thicker, and was pleasantly surprised at the shiny keychain engraved with the college’s logo on it. There was also a letter from the president, looking for money, but the package was much nicer. I don’t think the keychain impressed me as much as the thought that went into the package.
Colleges and universities are facing a huge marketing challenge. One of the designers in our creative department, Gina, recently sent around a great article that highlights the problem. Rick Green, a columnist for The Hartford Courant, made the observation that educational institutions are getting desperate. The marketing pool has gone down as a declining number of kids are graduating from high school and getting the attention of a student that age is not easy. Green’s point was that the quantity of mailings (and emails) have gone up significantly, but the effectiveness of these mailings is lower than ever. He also reminds us how quick and easy it is for his teenage son to completely disregard the endless stream of plain envelopes and form letters.
“My son just ignores all the letters, even though they appear to be from people who want to be his best friend. I’m fascinated because I see college is now somewhere between picking a political candidate and getting the free toaster from the bank.”Reaching prospective students and potential alumni donors is not much different than any other industry’s marketing challenge. You have to get your customer’s attention, engage them and motivate them to take an action. I could explain to you how we do that, but I’d rather show you. Take a minute to look at a few examples of colleges and universities that have used Structural Graphics for their donor and recruitment marketing.
So there I was, keychain in hand, deciding if I should make a donation to my alma mater this year. For my wife, the decision was an easy one. Besides the generic form letter, the school hadn’t even bothered to personalize it with her name. “Dear Graduate” is not too heart-warming and personal. I sent my school a check, albeit a small one, if for nothing else than to let them know this marketer was impressed. For them, I am sure an “A” for effort counts as something, but a response is worth so much more.